Store Hours: Sun-Thur: 11am-5pm, Fri & Sat. 10am-5pm
Come experience our old Cape Cod setting to see what we have, Just Picked for you!
Mini Hot Sauce Set
Set of four 5 oz. hot sauces in a shippable gift box. Set includes each of our hot sauces. Cape Cod Cranberry Lime Cherry Pepper Shark Bait Jalapeno Shipwreck Hurricane...
Regular price $3499 $34.99
The Spicy Shark Hot Honey
The Spicy Shark Hot Honey A special blend of 100% pure USA Clover, Alfalfa, and Goldenrod Grade A Honey. We steep the honey with a touch of Cinnamon and infuse...
Regular price $999 $9.99
The Spicy Shark Megalodon Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce
The Spicy Shark Megalodon Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce Flavor with a hint of Cherry to start and finishes with blazing flavor of the Carolina Reaper Pepper Made in Portsmouth, New...
Regular price $699 $6.99
The Spicy Shark Tiger Caribbean Reef Shark Scotch Bonnet Hot Sauce
The Spicy Shark Tiger Caribbean Reef Shark Scotch Bonnet Hot Sauce Blended mix of coconut milk, pineapple, and native Caribbean Scotch Bonnet pepper brings tropical heat. Made in Portsmouth, New...
The Spicy Shark Original Habanero Hot Sauce
The Spicy Shark Original Habanero Hot Sauce Bold flavor of habanero is tampered with the sweetness of carrot and ginger. Made in Portsmouth, New Hampshire 5 oz glass bottle
Habanero Hurricane Hot Sauce - Lighthouse Keepers Pantry
Habanero Hurricane Hot Sauce by Lighthouse Keepers Pantry This vinegary profile is well balanced with hot habanero peppers and salt. This sauce makes a great recipe starter for dressings, dips,...
Regular price $1099 $10.99
Jalapeno Shipwreck Hot Sauce - Lighthouse Keepers Pantry
Jalapeno Shipwreck Hot Sauce by Lighthouse Keepers Pantry This blend of bright and tangy lime, savory garlic and spicy jalapenos carries a mild heat with a lot of flavor. It’s...
Cherry Pepper Shark Bait Hot Sauce - Lighthouse Keepers Pantry
Cherry Pepper Shark Bait Hot Sauce by Lighthouse Keepers Pantry Tangy and bright with a mild heat, you’ll love this hot sauce on warm chili, omelets or roasted fingerling potatoes....
Cape Cod Cranberry Lime Hot Sauce - Lighthouse Keepers Pantry
Cape Cod Cranberry Lime Hot Sauce - by Lighthouse Keepers Pantry Tart cranberries and bright lime are smoothed by smoky toasted coriander. The pleasant habanero heat will hit in the...
Cape Cod Beachcomber Mustard - Lighthouse Keepers Pantry
Cape Cod Beachcomber Mustard by Lighthouse Keepers Pantry Made with a blend of flavorful garlic and herbaceous rosemary, this mustard is a step above your traditional deli mustard. Its great...
Cape Cod Tomato Chutney - Lighthouse Keepers Pantry
Cape Cod Tomato Chutney by Lighthouse Keepers Pantry This chutney combines tomatoes, peppers and onions with a mild spice. It makes a great topping enjoyed warm or cold. Try it...
Cape Cod Horseradish - Lighthouse Keepers Pantry
Cape Cod Horseradish by Lighthouse Keepers Pantry A flavorful pairing of cranberries with brown sugar, horseradish, mustard, orange and wasabi, you’ll love it at first bite. Its great on turkey,...
Dr. Swine BBQ Sauce
Dr. Swine BBQ Sauce Use this BBQ sauce during the last 15 minutes or so to add great flavor to any meats you have on the grill. It is sure...
Dr Frank Swine Hot Pepper Sauce
This hot sauce is sure to be a favorite, adding great flavor to anything. Aged peppers, garlic, vinegar, and other spices give this all natural sauce an unforgettable taste. Locally...